Sanalda.comBETA

How is a substantial reason proved for successive fixed-term employment contracts in Türkiye?

Added: 5 November 2026

For successive fixed-term employment contracts, a substantial reason is not proved merely by placing start and end dates on each document. It must be supported by records identifying the concrete work, project or event that made every renewal genuinely temporary. Article 11 of Labour Act No. 4857 links a fixed term to objective conditions such as work that is temporary by nature, completion of a specified task or occurrence of a defined event. The same article provides that a fixed-term contract cannot be made successively more than once without a substantial reason and that, otherwise, the relationship is treated as indefinite from the beginning. Current case law published through the Ministry of Justice UYAP system also stresses that the label chosen by the parties is insufficient and that courts must examine the objective conditions separately. The evidence file should therefore show, chronologically, why the work was temporary, what happened to the need when the earlier contract ended, and why the same reason continued or what new reason arose when the next contract was signed. This article provides general information and is not an individual legal opinion on a particular chain of contracts.

Objective reason and the renewal chain

1. Map the complete chain before analysing it The review should not begin and end with the last contract. Put every contract, addendum, renewal letter, job description, workplace or employer change and actual break in work on a single timeline from the first hiring date. A short interval between two documents may not by itself divide the employment into two independent relationships; the real reason for the interval and whether work continued must be examined. If the employee performed the same continuing function in the same organisation with a similar assignment, signing a new document every year does not by itself prove a temporary need. If there were genuinely separate and completable tasks, each link is assessed on its own facts. The length of the chain can be an important indicator, but the legal conclusion is not drawn from the number of contracts alone. 2. Define the objective condition through the work itself A substantial reason must rest on circumstances that are verifiable and independent of the parties' wish to insert an end date. Completion of a specified project, a temporary increase in need whose end can be anticipated, or replacement of an absent employee may constitute an objective condition depending on the facts. Merely referring to a budget year, tender period, funding term or management preference for work that remains part of the employer's normal and continuing activity will not necessarily suffice. The file should identify the project's scope, the employee's role, the completion criterion and how the temporary need differed from ordinary operations. If the employer relies on a special statute that requires a fixed term, the current provision and evidence that the employee actually falls within its scope must be produced separately. 3. Test the reason again on every renewal date An objective condition at the first contract does not automatically validate every later renewal. If the earlier reason still existed when the next contract was signed, its continuation should be proved; if it ended, a new and independent reason should be identified. A documented extension of the same project is different from assigning the employee to the employer's permanent functions after that project has finished. Contemporaneous project schedules, customer or public contracts, temporary-leave records, information about the replaced employee's return and dated assignment records can show that the explanation was not invented later. A general statement created long after renewal is less persuasive if it conflicts with the duties and communications recorded during the period. The written clause and the actual organisation of work are evaluated together.

Actual work, consequences and proof

4. Compare actual work rather than document labels Words such as project employee or fixed term do not determine legal status on their own. Time records, organisation charts, handover documents, emails, work orders, project codes, performance targets and the status of employees doing comparable work may show whether the employee served a temporary task or the employer's continuing need. Evidence collection must remain proportionate: personal data, trade secrets and third-party communications should not be copied indiscriminately. The employee should preserve records lawfully available within their access, while the employer should preserve the integrity and custody of organisational records. For each disputed document, an evidence list should state its date, author or custodian, the contract period to which it belongs and the fact it is offered to prove. 5. Separate the consequences of indefinite status If successive contracts were made without a substantial reason, the Act treats the employment as indefinite from the beginning; that classification does not automatically establish every possible claim. Who ended the relationship, on what ground and on what date must still be examined separately for notice, employment protection, severance and other entitlements. Whether a letter stating the scheduled end date constitutes a termination notice, and which event starts a strict application period, can be decisive in a particular dispute. In its official decisions, the Constitutional Court has stressed that courts must address the objection concerning objective conditions and the related starting point for procedural time limits expressly. Current mandatory-mediation and court time limits should be checked from official legislation in force for the relevant event rather than assumed from an old example. 6. Organise proof by period and disputed proposition A practical file may contain four parts: the contract timeline, the alleged objective reason for each period, records of the duties actually performed and the documents ending the relationship. For every renewal, record the contract date, anticipated ending event, supporting document, actual assignment, difference from the preceding period and any break in work. An employer asserting continuation of a substantial reason needs period-specific records; an employee asserting a permanent need points to continuity in duties and organisation. In mandatory mediation and any later claim, the legal consequences should be tied to the relevant facts and evidence rather than collected under one broad label. Official sources: https://www.csgb.gov.tr/Media/crldhi51/4857-say%C4%B1l%C4%B1-i%C5%9F-kanunu.pdf, https://mevzuat.adalet.gov.tr/ictihat/1126603300 and https://eski--kararlarbilgibankasi.anayasa.gov.tr/BB/2021/54737.

Related topics

When does criminal insult arise in Türkiye?What is national and public holiday pay in Türkiye?What does personal property mean in Turkish family law?How does an employee terminate for just cause in Türkiye?What are the seller's and marketplace's responsibilities for an online purchase in Türkiye?How does an employer terminate for just cause in Türkiye?Is a lawyer mandatory when giving a police statement in Türkiye?What is the difference between rent determination and adaptation claims in Türkiye?Does unpaid leave affect social-security contributions in Türkiye?How are missing social-security contributions identified in Türkiye?How is a debt disputed in enforcement proceedings?How is genuine need proved in an eviction case in Türkiye?Can a statement be given without a lawyer in Türkiye?How are fraud and aggravated fraud distinguished in Türkiye?What happens when a fixture breaks in a rented home in Türkiye?How do you request deletion of personal data in Türkiye?What rights arise when an employee's wage is paid late in Türkiye?When is an eviction undertaking valid in Türkiye?What if a product lacks a feature promised in an advertisement in Türkiye?Under what conditions may workplace camera footage be retained in Türkiye?What can an employee do when wages are unpaid in Türkiye?How is job-search leave used during a notice period in Türkiye?How long is bereavement leave in Türkiye?How does a contested divorce proceed in Türkiye?Is an early termination charge lawful for internet subscriptions in Türkiye?How is a prosecutor's investigation file checked in Türkiye?How is an inheritance disclaimed in Türkiye?How is property damage established as an offense in Türkiye?Severance pay in TürkiyeWhen may spousal maintenance be requested in Türkiye?
Revision history

5 November 2026 — Article added.