Sanalda.comBETA

How is market value determined in a Turkish statutory pre-emption action?

Added: 5 November 2026

As of 9 November 2026, the amount payable in a Turkish statutory pre-emption action is not automatically the price written in the deed. The version of Article 734(2) of the Turkish Civil Code that entered into force on 25 December 2025 requires the judge to determine the market value of the share in dispute without delay. The pre-emption claimant must then deposit that value together with the land-registry expenses attributable to the buyer, in cash, at the place and within the peremptory period fixed by the judge, so that the money can earn interest. The object valued is the share claimed in the action, not an automatic purchase of the whole property. The statute supplies no universal square-metre multiplier and does not make the municipal tax value, the deed price or an advertisement price conclusive. The current register, official sale instrument, share ratio, nature of the property, relevant valuation date, comparable evidence and any court-appointed expert analysis must be examined in the individual file. The parties must be able to address the report's sources, the comparability of sales and calculation errors within the applicable procedural time. A very recent constitutional development is essential. In judgment E.2026/23, K.2026/162 of 16 July 2026, the Constitutional Court annulled the words requiring market value, the dependent remainder of the second paragraph and the related transitional rule. The judgment was published in the Official Gazette on 6 November 2026. Because the annulment takes effect nine months after publication, the current market-value provision remains in force on 9 November 2026. For proceedings after 6 August 2027, one must check the official text then in force and any intervening legislation; the former sale-price wording should not be assumed to revive automatically. This article is general information, not individual legal advice on the value of a particular share, an expert-report objection, a peremptory deadline or litigation strategy.

Scope and proof of market value

1. Confirm that a statutory pre-emption right and a defined claim exist Before valuing anything, determine whether the event in Article 732 exists. A co-owner in co-ownership by shares must have sold all or part of a share in immovable property to a third person who was not already a co-owner. A transfer of an inheritance interest under joint ownership, a transfer between co-owners, a gift, an exchange, a forced auction and a sale under State Tender Act No. 2886 cannot automatically be treated alike. The action is brought against the buyer and seeks registration of the sold share in the claimant's name. A current register extract, official sale instrument, journal and sale dates, the buyer's status before the sale and any notarial notification must be examined. Calculating a property value alone does not establish the right. If several shares were transferred, the exact fraction in dispute should be identified; the value of the whole property must not be confused with the value of the sold share. A general waiver of the pre-emption right and a written decision not to exercise it for a particular sale have different form requirements. If the right or a procedural condition is missing, even a detailed valuation report cannot by itself produce registration. Valuation is therefore a separate stage that follows identification of a valid right and a timely, properly directed action. 2. Distinguish statutory market value from the deed price and tax value The current Article 734(2) uses the market value of the share in dispute but gives no single data source or arithmetic formula. The price declared in the deed documents the transaction, yet after the 2025 amendment it does not automatically determine the required deposit. A municipal value used for property-tax purposes is also a tax measure, not necessarily the statutory market value. An online advertisement is an asking price, not the equivalent of a completed, verified and genuinely comparable sale. Depending on the evidence, valuation may consider location, legal and physical character, planning and permitted use, area, building characteristics, the share ratio, encumbrances and suitable comparable transactions. If the economic characteristics of a fractional share justify a conclusion different from merely multiplying the whole value by the fraction, that conclusion requires reasons; Turkish law does not prescribe a fixed generic discount for every co-owned share. The date for which the court requests valuation, the terms of appointment and the date adopted by the report must be explicit. A party should compare the source, date, location, area and legal status of each comparable instead of selecting a single high or low advertisement. The statutory word market value does not allow an unexplained number detached from the particular share and the court's evidential record. 3. Require an expert and comparable-sales analysis that can be tested The judge decides the legal issues and may use court-appointed expertise for technical market evidence. A useful report should disclose the official records reviewed, whether there was an inspection, the comparables selected, whether they were completed sales or advertisements, the adjustments made and the calculation leading to the disputed share's value. If a comparable is in another neighbourhood, has different development rights, comes from a very different date or is a separately owned unit, the report should explain why comparison remains appropriate. A report giving only a final figure without sources is difficult to test. Within the procedural period following service, a party may make specific objections. Rather than saying merely that the value is high or low, identify a wrong parcel, incorrect share ratio, duplicated calculation, unverifiable comparable, omitted encumbrance or wrong date. A request for a supplementary or replacement report should explain its grounds; the court is not bound to grant every request. Personal data and third-party land records must not be obtained unlawfully. Having official information collected through the court and making the report's appendices available for adversarial review supports both reliable valuation and fair proceedings.

The deposit order, annulment and deadlines

4. Track what must be deposited, where, and by which deadline The current Article 734(2) covers both the market value and the land-registry expenses attributable to the buyer. The order should make clear which buyer expense is included and how it is proved. Counsel fees, all litigation expenses or a seller's personal debt do not automatically become part of that phrase. The court fixes the total, the place of deposit and a peremptory deadline. The statute requires a cash deposit and preservation of the money so that it earns interest. A claimant should not assume that any bank transfer is enough: the file number, designated court account or cashier, amount and final day must match the order. The current text expressly says that registration in the claimant's name cannot be ordered if the obligation is not met within the peremptory period. Underpayment, a transfer to the wrong account or a last-day processing problem can therefore be serious. File the receipt promptly and verify that it appears in UYAP. The deposit is paid to the relevant person with accrued returns after the judgment becomes final. If the action is dismissed, withdrawn, becomes moot or is affected by a legal change, repayment and costs depend on the actual order and procedural rules. Do not rely on a fixed court fee or expert-fee figure copied from an older source; tariffs and required advances change. 5. Do not treat the Constitutional Court annulment as immediately effective Constitutional Court judgment E.2026/23, K.2026/162 was made on 16 July 2026 and published in Official Gazette No. 33422 on 6 November 2026. The Court reasoned that replacing the parties' contractual sale price with a market value determined during litigation could displace their intentions, create an unjust gain or loss for the buyer, and leave the pre-emption holder uncertain about the amount ultimately payable. It found that the competing property interests were not fairly balanced. Nevertheless, to avoid a legal gap, the Court postponed the effect of annulment for nine months from publication. It is therefore wrong, on 9 November 2026, to say that market value has already disappeared and only the deed price must be deposited. The present second paragraph remains in force during the postponement. New legislation may be enacted before the nine months expire on 6 August 2027. After that date, the official text then in force, any intervening legislation and the procedural stage of the particular case must be checked; the pre-2025 wording does not automatically revive merely because the later provision is annulled. The annulled second paragraph of Transitional Article 1 had applied the 2025 change even to previously filed actions, and its annulment follows the same deferred timetable. A pending expert report, deposit order or judgment should not be handled on the strength of a headline alone. 6. Recheck deadlines, evidence and official law on the transaction date The valuation issue does not displace the separate limitation periods for exercising pre-emption. The version of Article 733 in force from 25 December 2025 requires the buyer or seller to notify the other co-owners of the sale through a notary. The right expires three months after that notification and in any event one year after the sale. The related transitional rule preserves the former provision for sales made before 25 December 2025, so the new one-year outer period should not be applied retrospectively to an earlier sale. Keep the notarial notice, sale date, filing date, register and every interim-order service record in one chronology. Mandatory mediation for partition or dissolution of co-ownership is not the same dispute as a statutory pre-emption action; nevertheless, on the filing date, the current procedural legislation should be checked for the competent court, exclusive venue and any action condition. The court's actual interim order and the official text should prevail over a generic online calculator. Official sources: https://mevzuat.adalet.gov.tr/mevzuat/103249, https://www.resmigazete.gov.tr/eskiler/2025/12/20251225-33.htm, https://kararlarbilgibankasi.anayasa.gov.tr/kbb/pages/search/NormDenetimi?id=a2JiOjE3ZTFhZTVmLWE0YjctNDhjNy04MzE0LTdlZmFjMDk3ZDFmMw&type=NormDenetimi and https://www.anayasa.gov.tr/tr/haberler/norm-denetimi-basin-duyurulari/on-alim-hakkina-konu-payin-bedelinin-rayic-deger-uzerinden-mahkemece-belirlenmesini-ongoren-kurala-iliskin-itiraz-basvurulari-ve-iptal-davasi-hakkinda-karar.

Related topics

How is an employment contract terminated for just cause in Türkiye?WillHow are personal data erased, destroyed or anonymized?What are dispute resolution methods?Does the SGK employment exit code conclusively determine employee claims in Türkiye?Eviction lawsuitHow is work on a weekly rest day paid in Türkiye?When may a landlord evict a tenant in Türkiye?What is the purpose of a family-home annotation?When can compensation for unauthorized occupation be claimed?How is a subscription cancelled through e-government in Türkiye?How is a commercial enterprise transferred?What remedies apply to a defective phone in Türkiye?How long can night work last in Türkiye?When is a private-school fee refundable in Türkiye?What can apartment management do about a noisy neighbour in Türkiye?What does an occupancy permit mean in Türkiye?Can nursing leave be used in a block in Türkiye?How is a mortgage lien removed in Türkiye?Under what conditions can a complaint be made to Türkiye's Personal Data Protection Board?How is property divided after divorce in Türkiye?Whose name should utility subscriptions use in a Turkish tenancy?What rights apply when a package tour is cancelled in Türkiye?What is national and public holiday pay in Türkiye?How is parent-child contact arranged in Türkiye?What does an arrest warrant mean in Türkiye?How is pretrial-detention review conducted in Türkiye?How does judicial control work?What can an employee do when wages are unpaid in Türkiye?Why does the amount owed in a UYAP enforcement file change?
Revision history

5 November 2026 — Article added.