Sanalda.comBETA

Can workplace entry and exit records prove overtime in Türkiye?

Added: 5 November 2026

Card swipes, turnstile logs, biometric readers and other electronic access records may show when an employee entered and left the workplace and can be strong written evidence in an overtime dispute. Presence in the building does not prove that every minute was working time, however, and the absence of a swipe does not necessarily prove that no work occurred. The actual start and end of duties, rest breaks, shift system, remote work, off-site assignments, payroll accruals and bank payments must be assessed together. Current Court of Cassation decisions expressly treat workplace entry and exit documents and internal correspondence as evidence of overtime. In some cases, calculating hours solely from witness accounts without obtaining available access records has been held to be an incomplete examination. This guide provides general information under Labour Law No. 4857, the Overtime Regulation, the document-production rules of the Code of Civil Procedure and official UYAP case law. The particular access system, contract, period and evidence can change the result. This is not individualized legal advice.

The contract and responsibility

1. Identify the record type, source and covered period Begin by explaining what the system actually measures. A main entrance turnstile, department door, cafeteria, parking gate, staff shuttle, computer login, VPN, telephone exchange and production application capture different events. Check whether a card could be used by another person, whether the device clock was correct, how shifts crossing midnight were recorded and whether a system failure explains missing days. Raw events, a later summary spreadsheet and a human-resources report are not the same document. Where possible, preserve change history, a system description and the identity of the person who extracted the data. Match the claimed work period to the period covered by the logs rather than extending a handful of example days across several years. The Court of Cassation expressly includes documents showing entry to and departure from the workplace among records relevant to proving overtime, but the party relying on them must still connect the record to the worker and period in dispute. 2. Separate physical presence from actual working time A turnstile event proves a physical passage; by itself it does not prove uninterrupted work throughout the interval. Meal and rest breaks, changing clothes before a shift, waiting for a staff shuttle, staying for personal reasons and movement between security gates may need to be removed or classified according to the facts. Conversely, a home system login, customer visit, field assignment, business trip or use of another entrance may not appear in the main turnstile data. Employer instructions, the nature of the job and whether the worker was free to use the time matter. Outside a valid averaging arrangement, overtime is generally evaluated by reference to exceeding the weekly working period. It is therefore unsafe simply to subtract the first entry from the last exit on every day and label the difference overtime. The shift and rest-break arrangement must be read with the logs. 3. Compare timekeeping, payroll and payments day by day Entry and exit times should be compared with the shift roster, time sheet, leave and medical-report days, assignment orders, email or messages, production records, payroll and bank payments. If a card log shows 07:40 to 19:10 while the time sheet records eight hours, investigate whether the difference reflects rest, make-up work, averaging, leave or unrecorded work. Where a signed payroll shows an overtime accrual and payment, its evidential effect requires separate assessment; a reservation, absence of signature and the amount transferred through the bank may change the result. An accrual on an unsigned payroll should not by itself be treated as proof of payment, and the bank and other payment records should be reconciled. A table with separate columns for the date, planned shift, first and last event, breaks, calculated work, payroll accrual and payment allows both the parties and an expert to audit the calculation.

Claims and evidence

4. Account for the employer's duty to create and preserve records Article 10 of the Regulation on Overtime and Work for Extra Hours requires the employer to prepare a document showing the overtime hours of affected employees, keep a signed copy in the personnel file, and show the resulting payments clearly in payroll and the wage statement. Article 75 of the Labour Law also requires records that must be created under legislation to be kept in the personnel file. These rules do not mean that every electronic access event must be retained indefinitely, but they do establish responsibility for creating the mandatory working-time and wage documents. Workers should keep payrolls, rosters and wage statements supplied to them before a dispute begins. When an employer replaces a system, records relevant to an existing dispute or official request should not be lost through the ordinary deletion cycle. Access should be restricted to authorized personnel and record integrity preserved. 5. Use document production and other evidence when logs are withheld Access data is often held only by the employer. A request should identify the device, date range and employee identifier rather than demand vaguely that every record be produced. Article 220 of the Code of Civil Procedure permits a court to order production within a final period when a document is necessary for proof and shown to be in the opposing party's possession. If the party fails to produce it without an acceptable justification, the court may, depending on the circumstances, accept the other party's account of the document's contents. The Court of Cassation has found an examination incomplete where available entry and exit records relied on by the defendant were not obtained before hours were calculated solely from witnesses. It has also required records supplied by an employee to be evaluated. If logs do not exist, witnesses with direct knowledge of the work pattern, correspondence and other documents may be considered; evidence from someone unfamiliar with the workplace or based only on hearsay may carry little weight. 6. Preserve the evidence promptly and define the claim correctly A worker may request preservation before the relevant dates are deleted and should lawfully retain payroll, messages and email already accessible to the worker, without unnecessarily copying other employees' private information. An employer should produce only the relevant person and period with an integrity trail and explain how the card number maps to the worker. Periods covered by complete, reliable written records may be calculated separately from periods supported only by witness evidence. Official UYAP decisions indicate that a reduction associated with estimated witness-based calculations should not automatically be applied to a calculation established by written records. In a mediation application, identify the period, ordinary schedule, claimed days and hours, payments received and supporting evidence. Under Law No. 7036, mediation before litigation is generally mandatory for an employee receivable action. Sources: https://www.csgb.gov.tr/Media/gekgpqcm/i%C5%9F-kanununa-ili%C5%9Fkin-fazla-%C3%A7al%C4%B1%C5%9Fma-ve-fazla-s%C3%BCrelerle-%C3%A7al%C4%B1%C5%9Fma-y%C3%B6netmeli%C4%9Fi.pdf, https://mevzuat.adalet.gov.tr/ictihat/1218275200, https://mevzuat.adalet.gov.tr/ictihat/1219855600, https://mevzuat.adalet.gov.tr/ictihat/401541400 and https://www.resmigazete.gov.tr/eskiler/2017/10/20171025-8.htm. The law and the particular recording system should be verified again on the transaction date.

Related topics

How does civil liability of company directors arise?How is a workplace accident reported in Türkiye?Is unused annual leave pay calculated from the final basic wage in Türkiye?When can custody be changed in Türkiye?How is a mortgage lien removed in Türkiye?How are missing social-security contributions identified in Türkiye?What should a tenant do if the landlord refuses to accept the keys in Türkiye?Disclaimer of inheritanceUnder what criteria may freedom of expression be restricted?What is the time limit for reinstatement claims in Türkiye?What should be done after a rent-debt payment order in Türkiye?When is an eviction undertaking valid in Türkiye?How is market value determined in a Turkish statutory pre-emption action?How is a reserved share in inheritance assessed?What safeguards are included in the right to a fair trial?What should be done when an online-marketplace order does not arrive in Türkiye?When is a deposit payment refundable in Türkiye?What is evidence in law?How is a foreign divorce judgment recognized in Türkiye?What is the right of defense?How is an inheritance-partition agreement made in Türkiye?What happens after dismissal for union membership in Türkiye?How is a fake social-media account reported in Türkiye?Which costs may a landlord deduct from a security deposit in Türkiye?Is creating a fake social-media account a crime in Türkiye?What conditions govern adoption?How is return of rental keys proved in Türkiye?How long may an authorized repair take in Türkiye?How is a rent-adaptation case filed in Türkiye?How is a comparable rent proved in a Turkish rent-determination case?
Revision history

5 November 2026 — Article added.