Sanalda.comBETA

Who is responsible for a defect in a second-hand product in Türkiye?

Added: 5 November 2026

A used phone may have diminished battery capacity, which differs from ordinary wear that the seller clearly disclosed. By contrast, discovering previous liquid damage in a phone advertised as 'problem-free' may support a claim that it did not conform to the contract at delivery. To identify the responsible party, first establish who contracted with whom, what qualities were promised and which defects were disclosed before sale. For a business-to-consumer sale in Türkiye, Consumer Protection Law No. 6502 and the Ministry of Trade's defective-goods guidance provide the main framework. A sale between two people acting outside commercial activity does not automatically follow the same consumer-complaint route; the Turkish Code of Obligations must be assessed separately. The label 'second-hand' does not, by itself, remove all defect rights, but it is not identical to a new-goods warranty. This general explanation cannot replace advice based on the actual contract, evidence and currently applicable law.

The contract and responsibility

1. Identify the parties and their roles Check who is named as seller on the invoice, order confirmation or listing. If a business sells goods to a consumer in its commercial activity, the seller is the primary addressee for a defective-goods claim; a marketplace account does not eliminate the need to identify the contracting seller. A neighbour selling their own used bicycle to another individual may be a different legal relationship. Without establishing the parties' roles, one cannot simply say a consumer arbitration committee has jurisdiction or that the platform always replaces the seller. 2. Compare promised qualities with disclosed defects Age and ordinary wear do not by themselves decide whether a product is defective. The listing as it appeared on the sale date, photographs, messages, service report and delivery record may show what qualities were agreed. The Ministry distinguishes a defect the buyer knew or should have known about from a different, undisclosed defect. A disclosed scratch on a laptop is not the same allegation as an undisclosed motherboard failure. Nor can a label accepting a defect make it lawful to market a product that violates mandatory safety rules. 3. Direct the statutory remedy to the right party In a consumer transaction, the seller must deliver conforming goods. If a defect is established, the consumer may, subject to the conditions, cancel the contract, seek a proportionate price reduction, request free repair where it is not excessively costly, or seek an equivalent non-defective item if possible. An identical defect-free used model may be unavailable; disproportionate hardship for repair or replacement can also affect the options. Statutory responsibility of a producer or importer for repair and replacement needs separate assessment. Do not automatically send every demand to the carrier or marketplace.

Claims and evidence

4. Check time and proof against the actual dates Law No. 6502 prevents liability for defects in second-hand consumer sales from being shortened below a statutory minimum; a separate rule applies to real estate. The general period runs from delivery, which may differ from the listing or invoice date. The Ministry's guidance also explains the presumption of proof for defects appearing soon after delivery and an exception where a defect was concealed by gross fault or fraud. Do not calculate a final filing date from this summary: the sale date, type of goods, agreement and official law in force for the transaction must be reviewed together. 5. Separate sales between private individuals If the seller is a person not acting for commercial or professional purposes, the statutory definition of a consumer transaction may not be met. The Turkish Code of Obligations rules on sales defects, examination and notification can then matter. Do not confuse these examination and notice duties with consumer rights against a business seller; the effect of a liability exclusion in a private sale also depends on the circumstances. The saved listing, payment transfer and correspondence help show with whom and on what terms the buyer contracted. A lawyer can assess the competent forum and time limits for that kind of contract. 6. Record the claim and evidence carefully Note when the symptom first appeared, the condition on delivery, the promised qualities and, where possible, an independent technical assessment. In a written notice to the seller, identify the item, defect and remedy sought; retain replies and shipping or service receipts. For a consumer transaction, check the current official arbitration-committee or court route according to the amount and dispute type; do not assume it applies to a private sale. Sources: https://tuketici.ticaret.gov.tr/yayinlar/tuketici-bilgi-rehberi/ayipli-mal-ve-hizmetler-hakkinda-bilgilendirme and https://www.tbmm.gov.tr/Yasama/Kanun/F72877BD-E416-037B-E050-007F01005610. This is general information.

Related topics

How should an apartment management track unpaid maintenance fees in Türkiye?How is property damage established as an offense in Türkiye?How is a family-home annotation registered in Türkiye?How is overtime proved in Türkiye?How is a power of attorney given to a lawyer in Türkiye?How does an employee terminate for just cause in Türkiye?Can an employer inspect an employee's phone in Türkiye?How does employment termination for retirement work in Türkiye?When does notice compensation arise?How is compensation for unlawful occupation claimed in Türkiye?How can commercial electronic message permission be withdrawn in Türkiye?How long can a probation period be in a Turkish employment contract?What happens if a reasoned judgment is not served in Türkiye?How is electronic service viewed in Türkiye?When may rent be increased in Türkiye?Can a divorce case be viewed through e-government in Türkiye?How are the acquisition and service dates proved in a new owner's need-based eviction notice in Türkiye?What happens when a protection order is breached in Türkiye?How is annual leave calculated in Türkiye?How is a valid will prepared in Türkiye?Is joint custody possible in Türkiye?How is a foreign divorce judgment recognized in Türkiye?How is a contractual penalty applied?Is a consultation with an occupational physician confidential in Türkiye?How is a finality annotation obtained for a divorce judgment in Türkiye?How is property divided after divorce in Türkiye?How is an internet-contract early termination charge calculated in Türkiye?How is divorce for abandonment filed in Türkiye?What is absolute nullity?What is an individual constitutional complaint?
Revision history

5 November 2026 — Article added.