Sanalda.comBETA

Do turnstile and access-card logs prove all of an employee's working time in Türkiye?

Added: 5 November 2026

A turnstile or staff-card log may show that an employee passed a door or checkpoint at a particular moment, but it does not conclusively establish by itself that every minute between two events was spent working. In an overtime dispute, it is necessary to examine which device produced the log, whether every entrance was covered, how breaks appear in the system, whether duties were performed away from the premises and whether the records were preserved without alteration. A recent Court of Cassation judgment published through the Ministry of Justice's official UYAP Case-Law Program says that, when an employer does not produce entry-and-exit records despite a proper order, the consequences of the Code of Civil Procedure rules on production of documents must be assessed. The same judgment shows that a period covered by records and a period without records cannot automatically be calculated on the same assumptions. The Ministry of Labour and Social Security also explains that employers must document working time through appropriate means and retain a signed record of overtime in the personnel file. Card data can therefore be strong documentary evidence, but it should be compared with rosters, time sheets, task orders, work communications, payroll and bank payments. If a biometric turnstile is used, proportionality and data-security duties under the personal-data rules also arise. This guide is general information, not legal advice for an individual case.

Coverage and evidential value of access logs

1. Identify what the record actually shows An access event may contain a date, time, door or device and an identifier linked to a member of staff. It commonly proves passage into a site or restricted zone; it may not be the exact moment work began or ended. Changing clothes, waiting for transport, eating, security screening and movement between buildings may matter. If work is remote, at a customer site or in the field, or if an entrance does not require a card, the system may cover only part of the work. Conversely, an employee may remain on the premises after swiping without continuing to perform duties. The device's purpose, coverage, mandatory-use rule and exceptions must therefore be understood before treating the interval from first entry to last exit as working time. 2. Test integrity and attribution The system, period and export method used to create a table submitted in a dispute should be explained. Raw events and a later spreadsheet summary may not carry the same evidential weight; missing days, time-zone settings, seasonal clock changes, device faults and manual corrections require examination. Attribution can also be affected by card sharing, several cards assigned to one employee or replacement of a lost card. The employer should preserve administrator events, the device list and change history, while an employee should identify the date and source of any screenshot. Absence of a signature, electronic authentication or system explanation does not automatically make a record worthless, but it increases the need to confirm authenticity through other material. 3. Do not confuse presence with breaks Under the Labour Act, rest breaks are not counted as working time. If employees are not required to leave through the turnstile during a break, however, access logs do not show when the break began or ended. Canteen-card events, production stops or a roster may assist, but should be compared with actual practice. If the employee says they remained at the post, answered calls or could not rest freely, those circumstances need separate examination. Mere presence on the site does not prove that no break was provided. The law, contract, shift pattern and work actually performed should be considered together; a mechanical identical break deduction from every access interval can be unreliable when period-specific evidence exists.

Production, period comparison and personal data

4. Account for the employer's record and production duties Current Ministry guidance explains that employers must announce daily starting, finishing and rest times, document working time by appropriate means and retain a signed record showing overtime hours in the personnel file. Access logs may form part of that system, but should not automatically be treated as a complete substitute for rosters and the overtime record. In a recent Court of Cassation decision, the employer failed to produce entry-and-exit records for the whole period despite a properly notified final time limit. The court held that deciding without considering the consequences under Article 220 of the Code of Civil Procedure was erroneous. The existence, holder and relevant period of the requested records should be specified, and potentially relevant records should not be destroyed once their preservation becomes necessary. 5. Compare each period with its own evidence For months with logs, daily events should be matched with rosters, time sheets, leave, sickness, holidays and assignment records. If payroll or bank records show an overtime payment, proof of the hours and proof of payment remain separate; a sum genuinely paid is not recovered twice. A sample from a few recorded months is not automatically projected over every unrecorded period. Witnesses should explain when they directly observed the same workplace and work pattern, and the nature and intensity of the duties should also be considered. In the recent UYAP judgment, unspecific witness statements were insufficient for a period without entry-and-exit records where a three-shift system was otherwise established. Recorded and unrecorded periods therefore require distinct reasoning. 6. Protect personal data and build a practical file Magnetic-card and turnstile movements are personal data relating to the employee. Their possible use as evidence does not justify unlimited collection or disclosure. Data Protection Board decisions show that proportionality requires particular scrutiny when fingerprints or facial recognition are used even though less intrusive card-based alternatives are available. The employer should define purpose, access, retention and security and remove unnecessary information about other people before disclosure. An employee facing a dispute should identify the period, device and shifts in writing and request preservation of the relevant events. Official sources: https://mevzuat.adalet.gov.tr/ictihat/1219855600, https://mevzuat.adalet.gov.tr/ictihat/685834800, https://www.csgb.gov.tr/Media/j2gell2h/%C3%A7al%C4%B1%C5%9Fma-s%C3%BCreleri-ve-%C3%BCcret.pdf and https://www.kvkk.gov.tr/Icerik/7434/2022-797. Current procedure and time limits should be rechecked on the relevant date.

Related topics

Does withdrawing a complaint end a criminal case in Türkiye?How are individual rights protected in automated decision systems?How is legal parentage established?How is criminal threat assessed in Türkiye?What rights apply when a package tour is cancelled in Türkiye?What are the requirements for self-defense in Türkiye?When may an employer inspect private messages on a work phone in Türkiye?How is a traffic fine challenged in Türkiye?What is an application to the European Court of Human Rights?How is return of rental keys proved in Türkiye?How is the right to be forgotten applied?What does acquired property mean in Turkish family law?How does third-party intervention work?Must a tenant allow viewings of the home in Türkiye?How is overtime pay calculated in Türkiye?Can compensation be claimed for an electricity outage in Türkiye?What does irretrievable breakdown of marriage mean in Türkiye?What does a lawyer do?What is the difference between a notice, payment order and eviction claim for unpaid rent in Türkiye?How is a subscription cancelled through e-government in Türkiye?How is a power of attorney given to a lawyer in Türkiye?Is short-term home rental lawful in Türkiye?Do return and defect rights change for discounted products in Türkiye?What are occupational health and safety duties?How should an apartment management track unpaid maintenance fees in Türkiye?What is the legal marriage age in Türkiye?How is an appeal-to-regional-court deadline calculated in Türkiye?How is a paternity-disavowal case filed in Türkiye?How is the Constitution amended?How does employment mediation work in Türkiye?
Revision history

5 November 2026 — Article added.