Can a tenant deduct building dues paid from the rent in Türkiye?
Not every amount a tenant pays to an apartment or site management is automatically deductible from rent. Article 20 of the Turkish Condominium Act primarily places the duty to contribute to common expenses and advances on the unit owner. Article 22 also makes a person who continuously uses the unit under a lease jointly and severally liable with the owner for that debt and late compensation, but limits the tenant's liability to the rent payable and expressly provides that a payment within this rule is deducted from the rent debt. This statutory result is not an unlimited right to set off every invoice labelled as building dues. The demand must be identified as an Article 20 common expense or advance, linked to the correct unit and period, and supported by proof of what management demanded and what the tenant actually paid. A lease clause allocating ordinary use expenses to the tenant may affect the final allocation between landlord and tenant, while management's statutory claim and the tenant's rent-limited liability require a separate analysis. If the tenant pays the same month's rent in full in addition to paying management, the result may be two payments rather than the statutory deduction, creating a later restitution or accounting dispute. A management receipt, itemised account and clear notice to the landlord are therefore important. Renovation, structural strengthening or an owner-specific debt should not be confused with ordinary operating costs. This is general information, not individual legal advice on a particular lease or account.
Nature of the dues and the rent cap
1. First identify the debt for which payment was made A management document using only the label 'dues' does not by itself establish the legal nature of the debt. Article 20 covers expenses and advances for personnel, common-area maintenance, protection, strengthening and repair, insurance, management and operation of shared facilities. A statement may also contain unit-specific utilities, a parking penalty, a former owner's personal debt or another item lacking a proper management decision. The tenant should request an itemised account identifying the period, decision, operating budget and unit. If the amount relates to a former tenant's occupation, a date before the current tenant moved in or an earlier owner, the relevant start and end dates must be separated. Before any rent deduction, determine whether the payment falls within Article 20 and whether the tenant continuously used the unit during that period. 2. Apply the rent cap in Article 22 correctly Article 22 makes the owner and a tenant who continuously uses the unit jointly and severally liable for the common expense, advance and late compensation. The tenant's liability to management is nevertheless limited to the rent payable, and a payment within that rule is deducted from the rent debt. Official case law likewise explains that the owner is primarily responsible while the tenant is jointly liable up to the monthly rent. If management demands more than the rent for a period, the tenant's statutory liability does not exceed that cap, while the owner's liability for the balance may continue. Whether the cap is applied month by month or across accumulated periods must be assessed against the periods and enforcement demand in the actual case. Principal, late compensation and the rent payable for each month should be shown on separate lines. 3. Document the payment and notice in the same file A payment deducted under Article 22 should be a real transfer to management that can be linked to the unit and period. Stating the site, unit and period in the bank description and obtaining a stamped or electronically verifiable receipt improves proof. The tenant should promptly send the landlord the demand, payment record and a written explanation of the amount deducted from a specified month's rent. Merely sending less money to the rent account without explaining the statutory deduction can trigger an allegation of rent default. If both management and landlord demand the same amount, obtain separate statements for the two asserted debts. If the landlord proves that the management debt was already paid or cancelled, checking with management before a second transfer prevents unnecessary duplicate payment.
Set-off evidence and dispute management
4. Separate contractual allocation from statutory collection A lease may allocate ordinary operating dues, heating, water or cleaning expenses to the tenant, and Article 314 of the Code of Obligations addresses the tenant's obligation to pay rent and applicable ancillary expenses. Articles 302 and 303 contain general rules concerning compulsory insurance, taxes and ancillary expenses, which must be read with the type of lease and any special provisions. A major renovation, structural strengthening, façade project or fundamental alteration does not automatically become the tenant's final burden merely because management calls it dues. Even if management collects from the tenant under Article 22, the tenant and landlord may have a recourse or accounting claim depending on the lease and the nature of the expense. Management's power to collect and the ultimate economic allocation between the parties are different questions. 5. Prevent double payment and default with a period table Keep a monthly table showing rent, management's common-expense demand, the amount paid to management, the balance sent to the landlord and payment dates. When an Article 22 payment relates to the same month, the documented amount may be deducted and the remaining rent sent with a clear explanation. Deducting a disputed item unilaterally can nevertheless lead to a default allegation under Article 315. Written acknowledgement by the landlord, an itemised management account and express notice reduce that risk. If the tenant faces both management enforcement and a landlord's rent demand, the same evidence set should be disclosed to both rather than concealing one payment. Separate the undisputed portion from the disputed portion before late compensation and enforcement costs grow. 6. Check evidence, jurisdiction and mediation for the actual claim A management claim under Articles 20 and 22 and the rent account between landlord and tenant arise from different legal relationships. The competent forum depends on the parties and legal basis of the particular claim. Pre-action mediation may apply to lease disputes subject to statutory exceptions. The management statement, owners' decision or operating budget, lease, bank receipts and deduction notice should be presented chronologically. Current figures and late-payment calculations must come from official records; this article assumes no fixed rate or monetary threshold. Official sources: https://mevzuat.adalet.gov.tr/mevzuat/103807, https://mevzuat.adalet.gov.tr/mevzuat/103273?query=6098, https://mevzuat.adalet.gov.tr/ictihat/334468200 and https://mevzuat.adalet.gov.tr/ictihat/1107484700. Obtain legal advice for the set-off and enforcement risk in the actual case.