Should you request repair or replacement for a defective product in Türkiye?
A service centre saying 'repair first' does not mean that repair is the consumer's only option in every case. In Türkiye, Law No. 6502 gives several alternative remedies once a product defect is established. Free repair and replacement with a conforming equivalent, where possible, are two of them. The sensible choice depends on the defect, whether repair is feasible, whether an equivalent item exists and the statute's test for disproportionate difficulty. This guide compares the two requests through concrete examples and explains how to document the choice. The current law and the individual contract govern the outcome; this is not personalized legal advice.
The contract and responsibility
1. Identify the defect and the exact model A good that does not match the agreed example or characteristics, or lacks qualities reasonably expected of it, may require a defective-goods analysis. Preserve the date the problem appeared, model and serial details, invoice, product description and delivery record. A headset with one silent side and a phone delivered with the wrong storage capacity do not present identical repair possibilities. Record installation and usage circumstances fairly too. Do not open a device dangerously just to create evidence; an unsafe intervention may both harm you and complicate the factual assessment. 2. Ask what repair would actually involve Article 11 permits free repair as one alternative where it does not require excessive expense. Labour, replacement parts or other charges should not be imposed under that remedy. Ask the trader or authorized service centre in writing how the fault would be removed, which component would be changed and whether the promised function would be restored. Replacing a cosmetic part differs from fixing a battery fault that affects safety. Obtain the service receipt and a record of the work performed, rather than relying only on a verbal assurance that the item is fixed. 3. Check whether a conforming equivalent is available The statute also allows replacement with a defect-free equivalent where possible. This does not automatically entitle a buyer to a superior model or a different brand; the comparison starts with the contracted product. For a discontinued or individually made item, actual availability must be examined. Do not treat a bare statement that the model is out of stock as a complete explanation. Ask for the proposed replacement's specifications and the terms of the exchange in writing. Consider separately whether you wish to accept an item with materially different characteristics.
Claims and evidence
4. Assess disproportionate difficulty with reasons If free repair or replacement would impose disproportionate difficulty on the seller, rescission or a price reduction proportionate to the defect may become the relevant alternatives. The law directs attention to the goods' value without the defect, the significance of the defect and whether another remedy would create problems for the consumer. Replacing an entire item for a minor, readily removable blemish may raise a different question from the loss of an essential function or a recurring safety issue. Record the trader's actual explanation alongside your legitimate use needs; one price comparison alone is not decisive. 5. Put the chosen remedy on the service receipt The Ministry's after-sales guidance emphasizes the receipt when a consumer requested replacement but the item was processed as a repair. When handing over the item, have the document state explicitly whether you request free repair or replacement with a conforming equivalent, together with the date and product identity. Keep a copy. Delivery for technical inspection is not necessarily agreement to a repair. Send the same request to the seller through a durable channel and keep the correspondence, so that the right you selected cannot later be inferred solely from a service-centre code. 6. Build a file if the request is refused or delayed Ask for a reasoned written answer if the seller rejects the chosen remedy or implementation stalls. Arrange the invoice, first complaint, service intake and work records, photographs and correspondence by date. Check the current official rules for the product's authorized service arrangements, applicable maximum repair period and dispute route; do not copy an old article's deadline or monetary threshold. The appropriate consumer arbitration committee or court depends on the claim's value and nature. Official sources: https://tuketici.ticaret.gov.tr/yayinlar/tuketici-bilgi-rehberi/ayipli-mal-ve-hizmetler-hakkinda-bilgilendirme and https://tuketici.ticaret.gov.tr/yayinlar/tuketici-bilgi-rehberi/satis-sonrasi-hizmetler-hakkinda-bilgilendirme. Seek qualified advice for a complex case.