Sanalda.comBETA

How is exclusion from use proved for an occupation-compensation claim between co-owners in Türkiye?

Added: 5 November 2026

Where one co-owner exclusively uses property held in co-ownership or an undivided estate in Türkiye, another co-owner does not establish a claim for occupation compensation merely by proving a registered share. Under Articles 688 and 693 of the Turkish Civil Code, each co-owner may use the common property so far as this is compatible with the rights of the others. One co-owner's use is therefore not automatically unlawful from the outset. Under the Court of Cassation's settled approach, unless a recognised exception applies, the claimant must show that before the compensation period the claimant communicated a wish to use the property or share in its income and was prevented from doing so. This is called exclusion from enjoyment, or intifadan men. A notarised notice is strong evidence but not the only method: official decisions state that the fact may be proved by any lawful evidence, including witnesses and an oath. A bare demand for money, however, may not always explain a wish to use the property or participate in its income sufficiently; the wording, delivery date and property covered by the communication must be examined together. Judicially recognised exceptions may dispense with a prior exclusion notice where the property naturally produces income or is rented for income, the occupying co-owner denies the other's status, earlier litigation or enforcement concerns the same property, or a binding allocation of use identifies each party's area. The facts supporting an exception must also be proved. This guide provides general information, not individual legal advice about a particular property, notice or compensation period.

Communication and proof of exclusion from enjoyment

1. Identify the ownership form and actual use arrangement first Review the land-register entry, certificate of inheritance and any allocation or use agreement together. In ordinary co-ownership, shares are recorded; in an undivided estate, the joint right extends over the whole asset without separately disposable shares until division. In either case, establish which part each person has used, since when and on what asserted legal basis. If the claimant has a separate area used without dispute in return for the share, merely considering that area smaller or less valuable does not always support occupation compensation; judicial allocation of use, partition or dissolution of co-ownership may be the relevant route. The analysis differs where another co-owner withholds the key, blocks entry, collects all income or rents the entire property to a third party without sharing the proceeds. Photographs, leases, crop records, utilities, address records, key-delivery evidence and witnesses can explain the factual arrangement. Draw this basic map of ownership and use before analysing exclusion from enjoyment. 2. Make the communication state a wish to use the property or share its income Exclusion from enjoyment means communicating that the claimant wants to use the common property, establish an identifiable use arrangement or participate in its income. Rather than only demanding an abstract amount for the past, the communication should identify the parcel or unit and state whether the claimant seeks a key, access, rotating or divided use, rent income or a share of produce. Court of Cassation decisions accept that a demand for rent can amount to exclusion in its factual context, but not every message necessarily does so. A vague statement such as 'give me my right' may fail to identify the property and form of enjoyment. The date on which the communication reaches the other party, and expiry of a reasonable performance period stated in it, may become important for the starting date. In a 2026 ruling, the Court did not treat a home occupied personally by one co-owner as automatically exempt from the notice rule; it used the end of the period given in the formal notice. Do not transplant that period into another file without examining its own wording and service. 3. Preserve lawful evidence beyond a notarised notice in chronological order A notarised notice simplifies proof because it records both the text and service date, but settled case law does not make it the only permissible method. Service of an earlier pleading or enforcement proceeding, a mediation application communicated to the other party, correspondence with proved delivery, electronic communication, witness evidence and, where procedurally available, an oath may be assessed. It is important to prove receipt, not merely dispatch. Preserve email headers, message exports, postal receipts and service records in their original context; do not crop screenshots or expose unnecessary personal data. A witness should explain the words personally heard, the date and the act that blocked use rather than offer the conclusion that someone 'asked for a right'. Where several properties are involved, match each parcel or unit separately to the relevant communication and actual use. A unilateral memorandum prepared later does not automatically prove an earlier demand. Keep the chronology, delivery proof and the other party's response together.

Exceptions, compensation period and procedure

4. Do not assume an exception to the exclusion rule from a label Court of Cassation practice recognises situations in which the compensation period may be assessed without a prior exclusion communication. Official decisions list public property; land that naturally produces crops; a home or workplace actually rented for legal income; a self-contained income-producing business; denial of the claimant's co-ownership; a use agreement identifying each co-owner's allocated area; and earlier litigation or enforcement concerning prevention of interference, dissolution of co-ownership or occupation compensation for the same property. These examples apply through facts, not labels. A home capable of being rented is not the same as a home actually rented for income. The 2026 ruling required exclusion where the occupying co-owner lived in the home personally. A claimed orchard should be supported by evidence of its produce, who collected the income and the relevant seasons. Denial of co-ownership is more than an ordinary disagreement over use. The person relying on an exception should prove the fact and its starting date; otherwise the general communication rule may govern. 5. Separate the starting date, bad faith and calculation Proof of exclusion does not itself establish the amount of occupation compensation. Determine first when consent ended or enjoyment was blocked, when the occupying co-owner knew this and what part was used. Article 995 of the Turkish Civil Code makes a possessor lacking good faith liable for damage caused by wrongful retention and for products obtained or negligently not obtained. The Court of Cassation characterises occupation compensation as damages for wrongful use, not contractual rent. Depending on the property, calculation may consider actual use, comparable income, crop yield, market conditions for each period, the claimant's share and the occupied area. Exclusion or a recognised exception and continued occupation must be proved for every claimed period. An expert report should explain its assumptions, differences in date and location between comparables, and gross-versus-net income. A numerical expert calculation cannot cure a missing legal condition or a failure of proof; legal character, period, responsibility and amount remain separate questions. 6. Classify the remedy, mediation and court route from the actual dispute At the outset, separate a claim only for past occupation compensation from requests to prevent interference, regulate future use or dissolve co-ownership. Subject-matter jurisdiction, exclusive territorial jurisdiction, court fees, evidence and mediation consequences may differ. Article 18/B of the Mediation in Civil Disputes Act governs pre-action mediation for tenancy, dissolution of co-ownership, condominium and neighbour-right disputes. It is unsafe to place every compensation claim between co-owners in one of those categories merely because it concerns real property. If compensation is joined with a remedy that independently falls within mandatory mediation, the current precondition should be checked. A later notice or mediation step does not automatically move the exclusion date backwards for earlier periods. Before filing, organise the register, inheritance document, use and income evidence, all communications, service records and period calculation into one consistent chronology. Official sources: https://mevzuat.adalet.gov.tr/mevzuat/103249, https://mevzuat.adalet.gov.tr/ictihat/204000500, https://mevzuat.adalet.gov.tr/ictihat/648340900, https://mevzuat.adalet.gov.tr/ictihat/1093096900 and https://adb.adalet.gov.tr/Home/SSSorularDetay/2. Obtain advice on the specific file.

Related topics

How is a consumer arbitration application filed online in Türkiye?What is a regulation in Turkish law?When is a negative declaratory action brought?What does concordat protection mean in Türkiye?When do online return and refund periods start in Türkiye?How is inherited real estate transferred in Türkiye?How is violation of privacy established as an offense in Türkiye?What should you do if a certificate of inheritance contains an error in Türkiye?How is a package-tour contract cancelled in Türkiye?What happens when a fixture breaks in a rented home in Türkiye?Is letting another person use a bank account a crime in Türkiye?What should you do if you are billed after cancelling a subscription in Türkiye?What is a formal notice?Where is a neighborhood noise complaint made in Türkiye?How is a resignation letter written in Türkiye?How is a consumer arbitration decision challenged in Türkiye?Can consent to personal-data processing be withdrawn later in Türkiye?What does being summoned for a statement mean in Türkiye?What does stalking mean as an offense in Türkiye?What happens if a reasoned judgment is not served in Türkiye?What is the time limit for reinstatement claims in Türkiye?What are fundamental rights and freedoms?Is a blank eviction undertaking valid in Türkiye?What rights does a part-time employee have in Türkiye?How long is bereavement leave in Türkiye?How is a child's surname changed in Türkiye?How is payment for unused annual leave obtained in Türkiye?Does an unsigned payroll statement prove payment of overtime in Türkiye?Is a permit required for short-term home rental in Türkiye?How is a payment order challenged in Türkiye?
Revision history

5 November 2026 — Article added.