How does an employer prove a protectable interest in a post-employment non-compete in Türkiye?
For a post-employment non-compete to be enforceable, it is not enough for the employer merely to produce the clause or show that the former employee joined a competitor. Article 444 of the Turkish Code of Obligations requires two connected elements: the employment must have given the employee access to the employer's customer base, production secrets or information about the employer's business, and use of that information must be capable of causing substantial harm. In its judgment E.2023/153, K.2024/93 of 4 April 2024, the Constitutional Court likewise explained that a non-compete cannot apply to every employment contract and that access to protected information and the prospect of substantial harm must coexist in the particular case. A protectable interest should therefore be proved through a proportionate chain of evidence identifying the specific current and non-public information the employee could access, the duties and permissions that enabled that access, the way the information could be used in competing activity and why such use creates a risk of substantial harm. This is general information and is not a legal opinion on any particular clause or dispute.
Protected information, access and harm
1. Separate the protected information from abstract labels Labels such as trade secret, customer portfolio or strategic information do not by themselves establish a protectable interest. The employer should first identify concrete information sets, such as a current non-public pricing model, customer needs and contact history, a production method, supplier terms, a product roadmap or critical data concerning business organisation. The substance of each set should be described without unnecessarily disclosing the secret itself. Records should show when it was created and last updated, who could access it, why it was not public and why it would have competitive value. Experience commonly known in the sector, an employee's general professional skills or a customer name available on the internet does not become the former employer's exclusive property merely because of the previous employment. The evidence schedule should distinguish the claimed protected interest from general knowledge and experience the employee remains free to use. 2. Prove actual access through duties and permissions A job title or a position on an organisation chart does not by itself prove actual access to particular information. The job description, project assignments, role-based permissions, system logs, customer-meeting records, confidentiality classifications, training records and handover documents should be assessed together. The evidence should identify which information set could actually be accessed during which period rather than merely asserting a theoretical possibility. It may matter that a shared folder was open to everyone, permission was removed long before departure or the employee saw only a final summary. An employer relying on logs should be able to explain their source, time zone, retention policy and integrity. An employee can preserve contracts, communications and permission records showing the genuine limits of the role, without unlawfully copying personal data, customer files or confidential business material. 3. Connect possible use of the information to substantial harm Article 444 requires more than access: use of the information must also be capable of causing substantial harm to the employer. That second link should not be presumed automatically. The employer should explain a concrete competitive scenario—for example, how a current bidding strategy could assist targeted solicitation, how cost information could support undercutting, or how a product roadmap could permit a rival to adjust launch timing. Loss need not already have occurred, but the risk cannot remain speculative and unlimited. The age of the information, customers' freedom of choice, market transparency, the employee's new duties, and whether the competing business operates in a different territory or product segment all affect causation. Instead of relying only on broad indicators such as company turnover, the evidence should connect the particular information, the proposed competitive use and the prospect of substantial harm.
Proportionality, termination and the evidence file
4. Match the scope of the restraint to the interest proved The existence of a protectable interest does not validate an unlimited restraint. Under Article 445, limits concerning place, time and type of work may not jeopardise the employee's economic future contrary to equity. Except where special circumstances justify otherwise, the period may not exceed two years, and a court may reduce an excessive restraint. The contract's territory, activity and duration should therefore be explained by reference to the actual market and useful life of the information identified in the evidence. A nationwide or sector-wide restriction on an employee who had access only to a defined customer group, or a long restraint based on data that becomes obsolete quickly, may raise proportionality concerns. Consideration promised by the employer can be relevant to the assessment, but it does not replace the requirements of writing, protectable information, substantial-harm potential and proper scope. 5. Test the termination ground and continuing real interest separately A restraint that was valid when agreed does not necessarily continue in every circumstance after employment ends. Article 447 provides that it ends when the employer no longer has a real interest in maintaining it. It may also end where the employer terminates without just cause or the employee terminates for a reason attributable to the employer. The file should therefore not stop at the document signed on hiring. It should include the termination notice and real reason for departure, the employee's final duties, the date access was closed, changes in the employer's activity or market and the continuing currency of the information. If a product was abandoned, the customer set changed entirely or the information became public, a former interest may not establish a real interest today. An employer asserting that the interest continues should support that proposition with records close to the termination date. 6. Build a proportionate and reviewable evidence file A practical schedule can use five columns for each protected information set: description, confidentiality measure, basis of the employee's access, possible competitive use and link to substantial harm. Add the agreement and its annexes, an access chronology, termination documents, a map of the relevant market and contractual scope, and an index identifying the source of each record. Personal data, third-party correspondence and trade secrets should be processed only to the extent relevant to the dispute; indiscriminate copying is not an appropriate evidence strategy. Claims for loss, a contractual penalty and cessation of the competing conduct under Article 446 each have distinct conditions, and the written reservation of certain remedies and the importance of the concrete interest require particular attention. Official sources: https://mevzuat.adalet.gov.tr/mevzuat/103273?query=6098, https://www.anayasa.gov.tr/media/9757/61_kararlar_04_cilt.pdf and https://mevzuat.adalet.gov.tr/ictihat/1162418500.